A couple years ago, I decided to stop doing Fandom Snowflake (
snowflake_challenge) because many of the prompts, while awesome, repeated from year to year, and I'd just gotten all I could from them. But this year, they are killing it with the prompts. Four have been posted, and I want to do them all. (Yes, this is a plug to go check them out if you are not familiar with them or if you, like me, stepped away at some point!)
I'm doing Day Three: Scream into the Void here:
So I'm going to go all deprived-toddler-in-the-candy-aisle about Tolkien fanfic fandom's disappearing archives. I want to clarify at the outset that I am not screaming about archivists who gave up or even "abandoned" their archives, even those who are popularly looked at kinda like >.> for doing so. Rather, I'd like to pound my tiny fists about the forces of fandom and the internet and, what the hell, the whole goddamn universe that have landed us where we are.
And where is that, exactly?? I was able to find three Tolkien-specific fanfiction archives that had five or more stories posted to them in the year 2022: the Silmarillion Writers' Guild, Stories of Arda, and the Valar Guild. Three. THREE. Tolkien Fanfiction and Open Scrolls Archive at least had a story posted to them in 2022, and nine sites remain available online but haven't had anything new for at least a year. Kudos on them for staying open but that's also pretty fucking sad that no one sees them as more than artifacts.
Back in October, I posted a preliminary archive timeline that was part of a roundtable I presented on at the Fan Studies Network North America conference. ( Read more... )
![[community profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/community.png)
I'm doing Day Three: Scream into the Void here:
I know Snowflake is sunshine and rainbows and singing from the rooftops all the lovely and brilliant that is being in a fandom. But, let’s be honest. Sometimes--like with other things--there are sucky parts, heartbreak parts and just plain UGH parts. Rather than holding onto those slights and resentments, or burying them and pretending they don’t exist, just to have them slowly and almost imperceptibly seep into the rest of the challenges this month, why don’t we just let it all out?
So I'm going to go all deprived-toddler-in-the-candy-aisle about Tolkien fanfic fandom's disappearing archives. I want to clarify at the outset that I am not screaming about archivists who gave up or even "abandoned" their archives, even those who are popularly looked at kinda like >.> for doing so. Rather, I'd like to pound my tiny fists about the forces of fandom and the internet and, what the hell, the whole goddamn universe that have landed us where we are.
And where is that, exactly?? I was able to find three Tolkien-specific fanfiction archives that had five or more stories posted to them in the year 2022: the Silmarillion Writers' Guild, Stories of Arda, and the Valar Guild. Three. THREE. Tolkien Fanfiction and Open Scrolls Archive at least had a story posted to them in 2022, and nine sites remain available online but haven't had anything new for at least a year. Kudos on them for staying open but that's also pretty fucking sad that no one sees them as more than artifacts.
Back in October, I posted a preliminary archive timeline that was part of a roundtable I presented on at the Fan Studies Network North America conference. ( Read more... )
Tags: